Chad Evans Wrongly Convicted

 

Investigation documents.

(note: the dates should be the date of the activity, such as an interview, but sometimes it may have been entered here by the date of the report. Bracketed [ ] numbers are "Discovery" pages, as submitted to the court in NH v. Chad Evans.)


1. Kittery Police Dept.

2. Maine State Police.

3. New Hampshire State Police.

4. Rochester Police Dept.

 

1. Kittery Police Dept.

9 Nov. 2000. Transcript of Jeff Marshall's 911 call to the Kittery Police

   (and other calls) (25 pages)[2996-3021]

9 Nov. 2000 Report of Kittery Police Officer Robert S. Creamer  He was

    the first police officer to arrive at 51 Rogers Road, the home of Jefferey

    Marshall, where Kassidy Bortner died. (2 pages) [5-6]

9 Nov. 2000 Report of Kittery P.D. Detective William Hackett re: 

    Detective Hackett took photographs at Jeff Marshall's

    home and then went to York Hospital and took photos of Kassidy

    Bortner's body.  Then he returned to Kittery where he had the

    three rolls of film processed. (2 pages) [3290-91]

9 Nov. 2000.  EMT (Emergency Medical Technician) report   of Robert

   Frechette whose team tried to resuscitate Kassidy Bortner at 51 Rogers

   Road and then transported her to York Hospital.  (2 pages) [1699-1700]

  Click for REKEYED WORD COPY of EMT report by Robert Frechette.

9 November 2000  Report of Kittery Sgt. Ronald Avery.  Sgt Avery

   arrived shortly after Officer Creamer.  Avery interviewed William

   Peirce.  (2 pages) [13-14]

9 Nov. 2000 Report of Kittery Detective Steve Hamel from his arrival at

    51 Rogers Road, shortly after Officer Creamer. (4 pages) [9-12] He

    reported that Sgt. Ronald Avery was at the scene and that he

    interviewed William Peirce, and that Chief Edward Strong was there. 

    Reports from Avery and Strong are not available and/or were not

    written. Hamel interviewed Jeff Marshall for this report.

9 Nov. 2000 Report by Detective Hamel of the demeanor of Amanda

    Bortner upon learning of the death of Kassidy (1 page) [3134]

9 Nov. 2000  Handwritten statement of F Jefferey Marshall

    (7 pages) [19-25]  Rekeyed WORD copy of Marshall statement

9 Nov. 2000 Handwritten statement by William Peirce  (2 pages)

   [15-16]  Rekeyed WORD copy of William Peirce statement

29 Nov. 2000. Report by Det. Steve Hamel of interview with Amanda

   Donnell  (2 pages) [215-16]

 

2. Maine State Police (MSP).

9 November 2000

4:12 p.m. MSP Detectives Jeffrey Linscott and Scott Harakles

    interview Jefferey Marshall (69 pages)[1265-1334. Page 1268

    is separate.] (A copy of MSP Det. Jeff Linscott's "Continuation

    Report" is included here, with pages 1335-1341. See below at

    5 January 2001.) This collection begins with MSP one page

    summary of Jeff Marshall interview, which is an NHSP interview.

    (See below, New Hampshire State Police, 9 Nov. Jeff Marshall.)

4:15 p.m.. Kittery Police Dept. Det. Steve Hamel and MSP

    Detective Jeffrey Smith Interview Jennifer Bortner Conley (77

    pages) [904-983] [First interview, 904-950, second interview at

    6:00 p.m. at pages 950-983]

 4:20 p.m. MSP Detectives Angela Blodgett and Richard LeClair

    interview with Amanda Bortner at the Kittery Police Dept. (66 pages)

    [820-885] For second part of this interview see below, 6:55 p.m. and

    also 10 January 2001, with "Continuation Report" of Angela Blodgett. 

    Also click here: Second Interview 9 November  (20 pages) [52-71]

 5:25 p.m. Summary of Interview by MSP Detective Erik Baker with

    Dr. Anthony Bock. (1 page)[1686] See DIAGRAM of bruises/marks

   on Kassidy's body.

 6:55 p.m. Second interview with Amanda Bortner by Det. Angela

    Blodgett and Det. Richard LeClair  (20 pages)[52-71]

 7:10 p.m. MSP Detectives Lance McCleish and Richard LeClair

     Interrogation of Chad Evans.  (130 pages)[1480-1609] The two-part

     videotape of Chad's three and-a-half hour Interrogation is available here.

     Click for: VIDEO OF INTERROGATIONIn 2010, Chad Evans reviewed

     the transcript of his 9 November 2000 interrogation and he added

     comments and explanations. 

     See ANNOTATED INTERROGATION TRANSCRIPT (REV. 7/14/10)

 8:00 p.m.~ MSP Detectives Scott Harakles and Jeffrey Smith

     interview Jacqueline Conley  (18 pages)[886-903]

 9:33 p.m.  Summary of MSP Det. Scott Harakles interview of Travis

    Hunt. (2 pages)[1213-14]

10:00 p.m. MSP Detective Angela Blodgett Summary of Interview of

    Nicole Harvey (2 pages)[47-48]  See also Interview of Nicole Evans

    Harvey by MSP Det. Angela Blodgett  (13 pages)[1806-1818]

10:05 p.m. MSP Detective Jeffrey Smith interview of Brandon Harvey.

    (10 pages)[984-993]

10:25 p.m. MSP Detective Jeffrey Smith interview of Robert Conley

     (8 pages) [994-1001]

unk. time. Signed consents to search, from Amanda Bortner, Jennifer

    Bortner Conley and Jeff Marshall. All three search consents applied to

    Jeff Marshall's home at 51 Rogers Road, Kittery.  Perhaps Amanda was

    consenting to search the few possessions she had stored there. (3

    pages)[1210-1212]

10 November 2000

 9:45 a.m.  Interview of Jennifer Bortner Conley by MSP Detectives

     Jeffrey Smith and Lance McCleish It was her second interview. (35

     pages)[1141-1175]

 2:20 p.m. Summary of Interview of Dr. Margaret Greenwald by MSP

    Detective Erik Baker  "...died of blunt head trauma with the possibility of

    Shaken Baby Syndrome." (1 page)[151, 1687(two copies of same report)]

3:00 p.m. "Examination Request/Evidence Receipt Maine State Police

     Crime Lab"  "Suspect/Defendant: Chad Evans.  Complainant: Jeffrey

     Marshall" Form delivered to Crime Lab by Detective Erik Baker.

 4:00 p.m.  Summary of Det. Angela Blodgett Interview with Virginia

     Grover (2 pages)[49-50]

  

12 November 2000

 1:00 p.m. Summary of telephone interview by Det. Jeffrey Linscott

     of Vicki Norman (1 page)[1264]

 1:15 p.m. Summary of Telephone Interview by Det. Jeffrey Linscott

     of Shannon Gagne (1 page)[1263] [See summary of second interview,

    below, of Shannon Gagne, by NHSP Sgt. James White, at 20 November

    2001.]

 6:30 p.m. Third interview of Amanda Bortner, MSP Detectives

     Angela Blodgett and Jeffrey Linscott  (74 pages)[72-146. page

    84 is missing, and is HERE-Page 84]

13 November 2000

11:40 a.m. Summary of Interview with Kris Keeler of NH Dept. of Health

    and Human Svcs. by Det. Erik Baker  (1 page)[1688]

 1:00 p.m. Summary of interview with Melissa Chick by Detective

    Jeffrey Smith (2 pages)[180-81]

 3:15 p.m. Summary of MSP Det. Jeffrey Smith Interview with Tracey

    Foley

    Assorted Evidence and Medical Reports (with most recent having date

   of 13 November: 20 pages)[1689-1709. Page 1694 separate]

    1. "Examination Request/Evidence Receipt," Maine State Police Crime

        Lab. 10 Nov. 2000, 3:50 p.m. "Suspect/Defendant: Chad Evans"

        (1 page)[1689]

    2. "Evidence Receipt," Maine State Police Crime Lab. 13 Nov. 2000. (2

        pages)[1690-91]

    3. "Authorization to Release Medical Records" York Hospital, 9 Nov.

        2000.

        (1 page)[1692]

    4. "Admission Record," York Hospital. 9 Nov 2000. (2 pages)[1693, 1695

        Page 1694 separate]

    5. "Certificate of Death", blank form, Maine Dept. of Human Services,

        together with "Record of Death" 9 Nov. 2000. (2 pages)[1696-97]

    6. "Progress Notes", York Hospital, (1 page) [1698]

    7.  EMT report by Robert Frechette. 9 Nov. 2000.  (2 pages)

        [1699-1700]  Click for WORD REKEY of EMT report by Robert

         Frechette.

    8. "Code Docuentation Sheet," York Hospital. (1 page)[1701]

    9. "Sheet #1" Front and Back diagram of bruises and injuries. (1

        page)[1702]

   10. "Emergency Room Report," York Hospital. (3 pages)[1703-05]

   11. "Assessment Referral Information," NH Div. of Children, Youth and

        Families. (4 pages)[1706-09]

14 November 2000

    Collection of Documents beginning with "Continuation Report" by

    MSP Detective Erik Baker.  (91 pages) [147-250,237-247

   separately]

     1. Detective Baker arrived in Kittery at 3:00 p.m. on 9 November and

        took photographs of Kassidy's body at York Hospital at 5:25 p.m. 

        Interviewed Jeremy Hinton and Kris Keeler and attended autopsy of

        Kassidy's body on 10 November. Baker Report (3 pages)[147-49]

      2. Summary of interview with Dr. Anthony Bock. (See above, 9 Nov. 5:25

           p.m.) (1 page)[150]

     3. Summary of interview with Dr. Margaret Greenwald. (See above, 10

         Nov. 2:20 p.m.) (1 page)[151]

     4. Summary of interview with Dr. Kris Keeler. (See above, 13 Nov.

         11:40 a.m.) (1 page)[152]

     5. "Examination Request/Evidence Receipt," Maine State Police Crime

         Lab. 10 Nov. 2000, 3:50 p.m. "Suspect/Defendant: Chad Evans"

         (same as above, "Assorted Documents" 13 Nov. #1. (1 page)[153]

     6. "Evidence Receipt," Maine State Police Crime Lab. 13 Nov. 2000.

         (same as above, "Assorted Documents" 13 Nov. #2 (4 pages)[154-57]

       7. "Assessment Referral Information", Division of Youth, Children and

           Families, regarding call from Tristan Evans, 31 October 2000 and

           related documents. (11 pages)[159-175. Pages 170-171 separate]

       8. "Continuation Report" Detective Jeff Smith. Last entry, 12 December

           2000. (4 pages)[176-179. pages 180-181 out of sequence. See

           below]

     9. Summary of Interview, Tracey Foley, 13 November. See above. (1

         page)[182]

    10. Summary of Interview, Melissa Chick, 13 November. See above. (2

         pages)[180-81]

    11. "National Comprehensive Report" database search for Chad Evans,

         vehicles, residences, neighbors. (17 pages)[182-98]

    12. "National Comprehensive Report" database search for Jeff Marshall,

         vehicles, residences, neighbors. (10 pages)[199-208]

    13. Vehicle Registration/License records for Tracey Foley, Melissa Chick,

            Gabriel Snyder. (4 pages)[209-212]

    14. Evidence Tracking reports. Audiotapes and Kassidy's car seat (from

         Jeff Marshall's home. (2 pages)[213-214]

    15. Summary of Interview by Kittery Police Detective Steve Hamel of

         Amanda Donnell. (2 pages)[215-216]

    16. Documents related to Search Warrant for Chad Evans, including

         application, warrant, and  Sgt. James White Affidavit.

         (13 pages)[217-229]

    17. Report by New Hampshire State Police Trooper William Graham of

         Arrest of Chad Evans on 16 November 2000. (1 page)[230]

    18. Report by NH State Police Sgt. James White of interview on 11

         January 2001 of Scott Strohmeyer. (1 page)[231]

    19. Report by NH State Police Sgt. James White of interview on 11

         January of Robert MacDougall. (1 page)[232]

    20. Report by NH State Police Trooper Shawn Skahan of interview on 24

         November of Barbara Hamel. (3 pages)[233-235]

    21. Report by NH State Police Sgt. James White that he had obtained the

         Divorce Decree for Chad Evans and Tristan Lea Evans. (1 page)[236]

    22. Divorce agreement and Support order. (11 pages) [237-247

         separately]

    23. Report by NH State Police Sgt. James White of interview on 13

         November of Stephanie Bolduc. (2 page)[248-49]

    24. Report by NH State Police Sgt. James White of interview on 13

         November of Kevin Callaghan. (1 page)[250]

   Documents regarding Search Warrant for searching Chad Evans car,

   actually owned by his employer, Colley/McCoy, a licensee of

   McDonald's.

      1. Request for Search Warrant and Affidavit, by Maine State Police

          Sergeant Matthew Stewart. (8 pages)[1249-256]

      2. Search Warrant and results. (4 pages)[1257-260]

15 November 2000

     

      "Report of Inquiry and Examination" by Dr. Margaret Greenwald

      (4 pages)[1098-1101] 

        "Report of Death"   prepared by Sheila Thayer, Office of Maine Chief

        Medical Examiner. (4 pages)

2:50 p.m. Summary of interview of Emily Conley by MSP Det. Jeff

     Linscott  (2 pages)[1261-262]

     Continuation Report, describing search of Marshall home, by Det.

    Herbert Leighton with enclosures (18 pages)[1192-1209] Enclosures

    included:

    1. Continuation report (2 pages)[1192/3, and copy, 1202/3]

    2. Evidence Control Sheet (2 pages)[1194, 1196, and copy 1205/6]

    3. 9 Nov.2000 11:45 p.m. Summary of Interview with Jeff Marshall during

        Det. Leighton's search of Marshall's home. (1 page)[1195, and copy

        at 1204]

    4. 15 Nov. 2000. Evidence Receipt, Jeff Linscott, Contents from Chad

        Evans Ford Taurus. (2 pages)[1197,1200 and copy at 1208/09]

    5. Two personal property receipts.

        a. 9 Nov. 2000. 11:42 p.m. Items from Jeff Marshall's home [1201, and

            copy at 1207]

         b. 15 Nov. 2000. 4:05 p.m. Hair and fiber from Chad Evan's Ford

               Taurus. [1201, and copy at 1207]

16 November 2000

12:25 p.m. Transcript of fourth interview of Amanda Bortner, by MSP

    Detective Angela Blodgett and NHSP Sgt. James White (18

    pages)[1992-1019]

17 November 2000

 8:30 a.m.  New Hampshire Complaint against Chad Evans for

    Manslaughter. Court appearance (1 page)

18 November 2000

19 November 2000

20 November 2000

21 November 2000

1:10 p.m. Summary of second interview with Emily Conley by MSP

    Det. Jeffrey Linscott (1 page)[1248]

 2:35 p.m. Summary of Interview of Heather Hamilton by MSP Det. Jeffrey Linscott (2 pages)[1246-47]

22 November 2000

   "Continuation Report" MSP Detective Scott Harakles. 

    Last entry was 22 Nov. (2 pages)[1215-16]

5 January 2001.  "Continuation Report" by MSP Detective Jeffrey

    Linscott Detective Linscott arrived at Kittery P.D. at 2:55 p.m. on 9

    Nov. Interviewed Jeff Marshall, Tristan Evans, Bruce Aube, Vicki Norman,

    Shannon Gagne, Emily Conley, Kristin Parsons, and Crystal Martin.  (7

    pages)[1335-1341]

5 January 2001. Summary of Interview of Crystal Martin by MSP Det.

    Jeffrey Linscott (3 pages)[1243-45]

10 January 2001. Continuation Report by MSP Detective Angela Blodgett

    (4 pages)[43-46] including other documents:

    1. Summary of interview of Nicole Evans Harvey by Det. Angela Blodgett.

        9 November, 10:00 p.m. (2 pages)[47-8]

    2. Summary of interview of Virginia Grover by Det. Angela Blodgett, 10

        November, 4:00 p.m. (2 pages)[49-50]

    3. Evidence Control Sheet for several items, mostly audio and video

        tapes. (1 page)[51]

    4. Transcript of interview with Amanda Bortner by Det. Angela Blodgett

        and Det. Richard LeClair.  9 November. 6:55 p.m. (20 pages)[52-71]

        For first part of this interview see above, 4:20 p.m. 9 January 2000,

        MSP Detectives Angela Blodgett and Richard LeClair interview

        with Amanda Bortner at the Kittery Police Dept. (66 pages)

        [820-83]  Also click here: Second Interview 9 November (20

        pages) [52-71]

12 March 2001. Two reports, 12 March and 8 March from Maine State

     Police Crime Lab (7 pages)[1185-1191]  (Included here - references

     to fingernail clippings with blood on ten fingernails.)

22 March 2001 Report of a DNA test on blood from Kassidy Bortner's

     fingernails and napkin (3 pages) [1947-49] The blood was Kassidy's

     and  the napkin had male DNA. 

 3 April 2001. Summary of interview of Gabriel Snyder by MSP Det.

    Jeffrey Linscott  (2 pages)[1178-79]

 6 April 2001. Continuation Reports: MSP Jeffrey Linscott (2) and MSP

    Richard LeClair (5 pages)[1180-84]

    1. 6 April 2001.  Continuation Report, Jeffrey Linscott (2 pages)[1180-81]

    2. 10 November 2001. Continuation Report, Richard LeClair (2

        pages)[1182-83]

    3. 28 March 2001. Continuation Report, Jeffrey Linscott (1 page)[1184]

6 April 2001. Collection of Documents, MSP  (23 pages)[1176-1200]

    1. 6 April 2001. Summary of interview of Robert Sheehan by MSP Det. Jeff

        Linscott (2 pages)[1176-77]

    2. 3 April 2001. Summary of interview of Gabe Snyder by MSP Det. Jeff

        Linscott (2 pages)[1178-79] (see above, 3 April 2001)

    3. 6 April 2001. Continuation Report, Jeffrey Linscott (2 pages)[1180-81]

        (See above, 6 April 2001.)

    4. 10 November 2001. Continuation Report, Richard LeClair (2

        pages)[1182-83] (See above, 6 April 2001.)

    5. 28 March 2001. Continuation Report, Jeffrey Linscott (1 page)[1184]

        (See above, 6 April 2001.)

    6. Evidence reports. See 15 November 2000, above for Continuation

       Report, describing search of Marshall home, by Det. Herbert

       Leighton with enclosures (18 pages)[1192-1209]

 6 April 2001. Full Autopsy Report by Maine Medical Examiner  by Dr.

     Margaret Greenwald. Date of report, 6 April 2001.  (35 pages)

    [1102-1138 (missing pages 1131, 1132)] (Another

    copy:  Autopsy Report, Kassidy Bortner (45 pages)[1096-1138 (pages

    1139-1140 irrelevant)] (pages 1131 and 1132 (age development charts)

     present here]  AUTOPSY BODY DIAGRAMS WITH INJURY NOTATIONS

 

12 April 2001. Supplemental Certificate of Death, Kassidy Bortner  (1

    page)[1097]

 7 November 2001. Supplement to Interview of Tracey Foley by MSP Det.

    Jeffrey Linscott and NHSP Sgt James White (2 pages)[3147-48]

 

3.  New Hampshire State Police (NHSP)

 9 November 2000.  4:12 p.m. MSP Detectives Scott Harakles and

    Jeff Linscott interview Jeff Marshall (report as "NHSP Continuation

    Report") 68 pages)[1266-1333] (See above, MSP report of same   

    interview, together with 1 page Summary and MSP Det Jeff Linscott

    Continuation report at 9 Nov, Maine State Police.)

9 November 2000.  8:00 p.m. Interview of Tristan L. Evans by NHSP

    Trooper John Marasco and MSP Det. Jeff Linscott (23 pages)

    [1074-1095]

9 November 2000. 8:45 p.m.-10:43 p.m. Interview of Bruce Aube by

     NHSP Sgt. John Marasco and MSP Jeffrey Linscott (19 pages)

    [1461-1479]  (This first interview appears AFTER the second interview

    (9/15) in the Discovery pages.)

9 November 2000. 8:50 p.m. Interview of Jeremy Hinton by MSP Det.

     Erik Baker and NHSP Trooper Jill Rockey (41 pages)[1764-1804]

9 November 2000.  Interview of Amanda Bortner, Jennifer B Conley and

    Jeff Marshall and Consents to Search Rogers Rd  (7 pages) [2988-

    2991,  2985-2987]

9 November 2000. Continuation Report by Trooper Jill Rockey (2 pages)

   [27-28]

9 November 2000. Assorted Documents re: Death of Kassidy Bortner (43

    pages)[1-42]

    1. New Hampshire State Police "Incident/Arrest Report", completed by

        Sgt. James White. (2 pages)[1-2]

    2. Continuation report by NHSP Sgt. James White. (2 pages)[3-4] (same

        report as below, 10 November, Continuation Report by NHSP Sgt

        James White.

    3. Kittery Police Dept. "Offense Report" by Patrol Officer Robert S.

        Creamer. (2 pages)[5-6]

    4. Kittery Police Dept. 911 report of minute by minute actions of EMTs

        and police (2 pages)[7-8]

    5. Kittery Police Dept. "Follow-up Report" by Det. Steve Hamel. (4

        pages)[9-12]

    6. Kittery Police Dept. "Follow-up Report" by Detective Sergeant Ronald

        Avery. (2 pages)[13-14]

    7. Kittery Police Dept, "Witness Statement Form" by William Peirce. (3

        pages)[15-17] [See also, rekeyed COPY in Word.]

    8. Statement Form and Witness Statement Form by Jeff Marshall (8

        pages)[18-25]

    9. Rochester P.D. Report from Det. William Carlberg re: Evans home. (1

        page)[26] 

   10. Continuation Report, NHSP Trooper Jill Rockey. (2 pages)[27-28]

   11. York Hospital records re: Kassidy Bortner. (10 pages)[29-38] including

        "Authorization to Release Medical Records" [30]

   12. Second page of a two page Summary of Interview of Ramon Aguilar

        by NHSP Trooper Jill Rockey. (1 page)[391]

   13. York Hospital records re: Kassidy Bortner. (3 pages)[40-42]

10 November 2000. Continuation Report by NHSP Sgt James White (2

    pages)[3-4]

10 November 2000.  Interviews of Jeff Marshall by MSP Det. Scott

    Harakles and Jeff Linscott and NHSP officer with initials, "HAM". 

    (74 pages, in two sections, apparently on different days, 1-16, 1-

    58)[1610-1682] (First section, pp 1-16, appears to be for 10 Nov.

    interview, and second section, 1-58, appears to be for interview on

    16 November, for videotaping of CPR-on-stomach demonstration by

    Jeff. (Page 33, [Disc 1657-A] appears to be out of sequence, as the

    end of page 32 does not lead to 33 and 33 does not appear to lead to

    page 34.)

10 November 2000. Assorted documents related to Security and Search

     of Chad Evans home  (64 pages)[3077-3148, pages 3126-29

   separately]

    1. Continuation report, Sgt William Magee (3 pages)[3077-3079]

    2. Crime Scene Security Log, Det. John Caldwell, Rochester Police Dept.,

        for Chad Evans' home. (3 pages)[3080-3082]

    3. Documents related to first search (37 pages)[3083-3119]

    4. Documents related to second search, for source of the "dry petechial

        type scabs" (description from Dr. Bock's Emergency Room Report) on

        Kassidy's feet. (6 pages)[3120-3125, pages 3126-29

        separately]

    5. Statement of MSP Det. Steve Hamel, as witness to advising Amanda

        Bortner of death of Kassidy. (1 page)[3134]

    6. Re: friend of Travis Hunt. (2 pages)[3135-3136]

    7. X-Ray reports of Kassidy's limbs. (4 pages)[3137-3140]

    8. Evidence transmission and custody reports (6 pages)[3141-3146]

    9. Summary of interview with Tracey Foley, supplement, MSP Det. Jeff

        Linscott (2 pages)[3147-3148]

10 November 2000. Among the items seized from Chad's home during the

    search were balls marked #11 (later State's Exhibit 17) and

   Ball #16.

11 November 2000. Transcript of Recording of conversation among

    Amanda Bortner, Jennifer Bortner Conley and Jeff Marshall. (9

    pages)[2962-2070] See also, same transcript (rekeyed) with

     Chad Evans' 2010 comments (rev. 28 Aug 2010)

14 November 2000. morning, and ended at 12:40 p.m. Interview of

     Jeremy Hinton by MSP Det. Erik Baker and NHSP Trooper Jill

     Rockey (60 pages)[251-312, pages 306-07 separately]

15 November 2000 Second Interview of Bruce Aube by MSP Det. Jeff

    Linscott and NHSP Det. John Marasco 11:15 a.m. (119 pages)

    [1342-1460] (This second interview of Bruce Aube appears BEFORE the

     first interview (9/9) in the Discovery pages.) [It was during this

    interview that Bruce mentioned a "note" written by Amanda, and

    the police tried to persuade him to retrieve the note from his home

    for them.  Subsequently, Chad Evans gave the notes to his attorney,

    Alan Cronheim, and he forwarded a copy to the police in the Spring

    of 2001. See the HANDWRITTEN ORIGINAL and the rekeyed version

    in WORD.]

16 November 2000.  Interviews of Jeff Marshall by MSP Det. Scott

    Harakles and Jeff Linscott and officer with initials, "HAM". 

    (74 pages, in two sections, apparently on different days, 1-16, 1-

    58)[1610-1682] (First section, pp 1-16, appears to be for 10 Nov.

    interview, (Harakles and HAM) and second section, 1-58, appears

    to be for interview on 16 November (Linscott and Harakles) , for

    videotaping of CPR-on-stomach demonstration by Jeff. (See above

    for 10 November 2000.) (Page 33, [Disc 1657-A] appears to be out

    of sequence, as the end of page 32 does not lead to 33 and 33 does not

    appear to lead to page 34.)

16 November 2000. New Hampshire Complaint against Chad Evans for

    Manslaughter "for causing Kassidy's death by inflicting blunt force injury

    to her head."  (1 page)

16 November Documents relating to arrest of Chad Evans and search

     of home (42 pages)[313-354]

    1. Arrest Warrant, Motion to Seal Arrest Warrant and  Sgt. James

         White Arrest Affidavit of 10 November. (11 pages)[313-323]

    2. Search Warrant, Motion to seal Search Warrant and Sgt. James

          White Affidavit of 11 November. (different from above) (13 

        pages)[324-336] [In 2010, Chad Evans annotated Sgt. White's 11

        November 2000 affidavit with his understanding of the facts.

          See Chad-Annotated Sgt. White Affidavit.]

    3. Rochester Police Dept Reports from Det. William C. Carlberg, Jr., Det.

        Eric P. Savitts, and Patrolman Anthony Deluca III re: arrest and

        search. (4 pages)[337-340]

    4. Continuation report by Sgt. James White re: short discussion with Chad

        Evans at Rochester Police Station. (1 page)[341]

    5. Report of Rochester P.D. Detective Anne M. Brideau regarding phone

        call on evening of 16 November from Chad Evans' attorney, Alan

        Cronheim, seeking to speak with his client. (1 page)[342]

    6. Report of MSP Det. Jeff Linscott and NHSP Det. Russell Conte

        interview with Chad Evans on evening of 16 November. (4 pages)

        [345-348]

    7. Report of Rochester P.D. Detectives Callaghan and Gero who

       interviewed Erin Entrekin at the Cross Road Kindergarten and Child Care

       center where Kyle Evans received day care. (2 pages)[349-350]

    8. Report of Rochester P.D. Det. William Carlberg re: information from

        Strafford County Jail cellmate of Chad Evans on 17 Nov.(1 page)[351]

     9. Summary of interview with John LaCroix, cellmate of Chad Evans on 17

         November. (2 pages)[352-353]

  10. Summary of 21 November 2000 interview of Kristin Parsons, by NHSP

       Trooper Jill Rockey and MSP Det. Jeff Linscott. (1 page)[354]

17 November 2000.  Interview of John LaCroix by Sgt. James White and

     Det. Carey Carlberg (11 pages)[2973-2983]

20 November 2000. Interview of Kyle Evans by Nancy Harris, Strafford

    County Victim Witness Program (33 pages)[1731-63]

20 November 2000. Continuation Report by NHSP Sgt. James White re:

    Observation of Kyle Evans interview  (1 page)[1730]

21 November 2000. Summary of Det. Linscott interview with Kristin Parsons

     (1 page) [354]

22 November 2000. Interview of Travis Hunt by NHSP Trooper Jill

     Rockey and MSP Det. Scott Harakles(54 pages)[355-389-U,

    including pages 389-A to 389-U, and missing pages 377, 378]

    See also copy of same Interview of Travis Hunt (58 pages)

    [2021-2077, with no pages missing]

22 November 2000 Assorted NHSP documents (12 pages)[390-402]

    1. Interview of Ramon Aguilar by NHSP Trooper Jill Rockey, 1st page (1

        page) [390][Second page of interview, 391, is missing from this

        collection, but is linked here as PAGE 391]  See 9 Nov. report

        above, Item 12] 22 Nov. 2000.

    2. State of New Hampshire Forensic Lab report on Meat Tenderizer seized

        from Chad Evans home. (1 page)[392] 22 Nov. 2000.

    3. Continuation Report by Sgt. James White. Report of visitors to Chad

        Evans at Strafford County Jail. 29 November 2000.  (1 page)[393]

    4. Continuation Report by Sgt. James White. Reports of receipt of 10

        strips of photographic negatives, from Kittery P.D. Detective Steve

        Hamel.  (3 pages)[394-96]

    5. Continuation Report by Sgt. James White. Hours worked by Amanda

        Bortner at Old Navy, during week of Kassidy Bortner's death. (2

        pages)[397-98]

    6. Continuation Report by Sgt. James White. Hours worked by Jennifer

        Bortner Conley at Perfumania, during week of Kassidy Bortner's death.

        (2 pages)[399-400]

    7. Summary of Interview of William Peirce by NHSP Sgt. James

        White, 6 December 2000. (1 page)[401]

    8. Summary of Interview of Amy Gagne by NHSP Sgt. James White, 7

        December 2000. (1 page)[402]

24 November 2000. Summary of Interview with Barbara Brooks Hamel

    by NHSP Trooper Shawn Skahan and Sgt. Allen Welch  (3 pages)

    [233-235]

 6 December 2000. Summary of Interview of William Peirce by NHSP Sgt.

     James White, 6 December 2000. (1 page)[401]

 7 December 2000. Assorted documents NHSP including timeline by Sgt James White and 1999 Restraining order re: Chad Evans 

   (89 pages)[403-493]

   1. 7 December 2000 Continuation report by NHSP Sgt James White

       regarding transmission of several balls, seized from Chad Evans Home

       during 10 November 2000 search. And separation of "green ball" from

       Exhibit WFM-26A. (2 pages)[403 & 406, pages 404-05  separately]

   2. 8 December 2000 Continuation report by NHSP Sgt James White

       regarding DCYF documents. (5 pages)[407-411]

   3. NHSP "Possessed property reports" for evidence, primarily audio and

      video tapes. (31 pages)[412-442]

   4. Chad Evans arrest records. (3 pages)[443-446]

   5.  Investigation status and Investigation Plan by NHSP Sgt.

         James White (4 pages)[447-450]

   6. Restraining order 15 December 1999 for Chad re: Tristan Evans.

       (7 pages)[451-457]

19 December 2000. 10:00 a.m.  Summary of Interview of Amanda

    Bortner, her fifth, by NHSP Sgt. James White  (4 pages)[615-618]

28 December 2000.  Summary of interview of Del Paone of Moonlite

    Reader (1 page)[619]

 2 January 2001. Summary of telephone interview by NHSP Sgt. James

    White of Eileen Valois of the Exeter Inn  (1 page)[620]

 2 January 2001. Summary of Telephone Interview of Robert McDougall

    by NHSP Sgt. James White  (1 page)[621]

 5 January 2001 Report of Phone Calls made from Strafford County Jail

    in Nov-Dec 2000  (9 pages)[633-641]

5-6 February 2001. Summary of telephone and in-person

    interview of Cory Merrill, Strafford County Jail, by NHSP

    Trooper Jill Rockey (3 pages)[1022-24]

 7 February 2001. Summary of interview of Craig Gautreau by NHSP

    Trooper Jill Rockey (2 pages)[1025-26]

 7 February 2001. Assorted NHSP documents, with the latest being 7

    February 2001 (11 pages)[1062-1072]

     1. Anchorage Inn receipt for Jeff Marshall, 9 Nov. 2000. (2 pages)[1062-

          1063]

     2. Summary of 5 February 2001 interview by NHSP Trooper Jill Rockey

         with Cory Merrill (3 pages)[1064-1066]

     3. Summary of 7 February 2001 interview by NHSP Trooper Jill Rockey

         with Craig Gautreau (2 pages)[1067-68]

     4. Summary of interview by NHSP Trooper John Marasco and MSP

         Detective Jeff Linscott of Bruce Aube. (2 pages)[1069-70]

     5. Report by NHSP Trooper John Marasco of attempt by Nancy Harris to

         interview Brent Richards on 15 December 2000. (1 page)[1071]

     6. Continuation Report by NHSP Sgt.Russell Conte regarding finding of

         live ammunition at Chad Evans home, and notification of his NH

         Probation Officer, Kevin Callaghan. (1 page)[1072]

 7 May 2001. Continuation Report by NHSP Sgt James White re: receipt

     of three pages of notes by Amanda Bortner  (4 pages)[1726-29]

     See also, Transcribed WORD Copy of 3-page Notes.

May 2001 - August 2001 Assorted documents mostly related to

    NHSP efforts to determine if Chad Evans was violating bail

    conditions  (62 pages)[1950-2020, but missing 1994-2001, and 2008]

    [Pages 1994-2001 related to surveillance of Chad Evans. Page 2008

    was a spare page about a car ID check.]

    Also included amidst the phone bills and surveillance

     records were:

     1. Application for court appointed-counsel by Amanda Bortner 9 May

         2001 and court denial. (4 pages)[1950-53]

     2. Summary of 12 August 2001 interview by NHSP Trooper Jill Rockey and

         NHSP Sgt. James White of Alan Noyes. (1 page)[1964]

     3. Summary of 12 June 2001 Interview by NHSP Sgt. James White with

         Jacqueline Conley. (1 page)[1965]

May 2001 - August 2001 Assorted documents re: NHSP efforts to

    determine whereabouts of Amanda Bortner and Chad Evans  

    compliance with bail conditions  (31 pages)[2079-2113, pages

    2089-92 separately] 

    1. Same application for court-appointed counsel by Amanda Bortner, as

        above (#1). Also included are Amanda's 2-page handwritten request

        and NHSP documents aimed at determining if Chad Evans palm prints

        were on that handwritten letter. (9 pages)[2079-2087]

    2. 13 August 2001 Continuation Report by Sgt. James White about

        information from Alan Noyes re: whereabouts of Chad Evans. (1

        page)[2088]

    3. 9 August 2001 Subpoenas, and related service of process reports to

        Vanessa Mansson, Charlene Truell, Bruce Truell, Chester Evans, Pamela

        Evans and Amanda Bortner to appear before a Strafford County Grand

       Jury regarding Chad Evans and Amanda Bortner. (18 pages)[2093-2110]

    4. 17 August 2001. Summary of interview of Cathy Nuernberg by

        NHSP Sgt James White. (3 pages)[2111-2113]

23 May 2001. NHSP Lab report for Chad Evans fingerprints (none) on

     Amanda Letter

14 August 2001. Summary of Interview of Vanessa Mansson by NHSP

    Sgt James White and Sgt. Kelly McClare   (4 pages)[2089-92]

14 August 2001.  Summary of Interview/Service of Summons of

     Amanda Bortner by NHSP Sgt Kelly McClare and Sgt James White

     (2 pages)[1959-60]

16 August 2001. Summary of interview of Jeremy Hinton by Trooper Jill

    Rockey  (1 page)[3128]

 6 September 2001. Interview of Eric Lepisto by Sgt. James White (3

    pages)[2992-2994]

25 October 2001. List of Visitors to Chad Evans at Strafford County Jail

    25 Aug. to 21 Oct.  Report compiled by Trooper Jill Rockey.  (2 pages)

    [3129-3130]

7 November 2001 Interview by NHSP Sgt. James White of Tracey

     Foley. (24 pages)[3149-72]

 9 November 2001. Interview of Melissa Chick by NHSP Sgt. James

     White and MSP Det. Jeff Linscott (26 pages, including evidence

    receipt)[3179-3204]

12 November 2001 Summary of interview by Sgt. James White with

    William Modlin (4 pages)[3174-77]

13 November 2001 Summary of interview by Sgt. James White with

     Stanley Staley (1 page)[3173]

13 November 2001 Summary of interview by Sgt. James White with

     Thomas McNeil (1 page)[3178]

20 November 2001  Summary of Interview by NHSP Sgt. James White

    and MSP Det. Rick LeClair of Mary Bullard  (2 pages)[3211-12]

21 November 2001  Summary by NHSP Sgt. James White of Second

   Interview of Shannon Gagne  (1 page)[3213] [See Summary of first

   interview by MSP, above at 12 November 2000.]

28 November 2001 Summary of Interview with Eric Cook by Sgt

    James White and AAG's Will Delker and Simon Brown  and Eric

   Cook Statement. (4 pages) [3285-87] See also, the 17 November

   2001 Letter to AAG N William Delker from Eric Cook.  (2 pages)

   [3293-94]

29 November 2001  Summary of Interview of Bruce Aube by Asst.

    Atty Gen. Simon Brown and NHSP Sgt. James White (1 page)

   [3288]

30 November 2001 Summary of NHSP Sgt White Discussion with

   Bail Comm'r Mike Mone re: Amanda Bortner Bail (1 page)

   [3289]

 

4. Rochester Police Dept.

16 Nov. 2000 Manslaughter Incident Report and Chad Evans arrest

    (2 pages)[642-43]

16 Nov. 2000 Chad Evans Arrest report by Patrolman Anthony Deluca

    (2 pages)[644-45]

16 Nov. 2000 Narrative of Chad Evans arrest by Patrolman Anthony

   Deluca  (2 pages)[646-47]

16 Nov. 2000 Narrative of Chad Evans arrest by Detective Eric Savitts

    (1 page)[648]

16 Nov. 2000 Narrative of Chad Evans arrest by Detective William

   Carlberg   (1 page)[649]

16 Nov. 2000 Report by Sgt. Anne Brideau of call by Chad Evans Atty to

   stop police interview of client   (1 page)[650]

31 October 2001.  Summary of interview of Travis Hunt by Det. Paul

    Callaghan, AAG's Will Decker and Simon Brown   (2 pages)[3132-3133]

31 October 2001. Summary of Interview of Irene Ricci by Det. Paul

   Callaghan and Det. Christopher Mangum     (1 page)[3127]